Many exercise myths persist, guiding people’s fitness routines with misinformation. If you’ve ever wondered about the effectiveness of exercising on an empty stomach, feared that weightlifting might lead to unwanted bulk, or been cautioned against running to protect your knees, it’s time to clear the air. Here’s the truth behind seven widely held exercise misconceptions.
Myth 1: Exercising Before Breakfast Burns More Fat
The idea that fasting before exercise burns more fat stems from the notion that with glycogen stores depleted, the body must turn to fat for energy. While it’s true that some fat is burned when you exercise on an empty stomach, research has shown that the difference in fat loss over time is negligible. According to Brad Schoenfeld, an exercise science professor at Lehman College, total fat loss is primarily influenced by overall calorie balance, not the timing of your workout. Studies indicate that whether you eat before or after exercise, fat loss over several weeks remains similar.
Bottom Line: If you prefer to eat before working out, go ahead—your fat loss will not be significantly impacted by whether you exercise on an empty stomach or not.
Myth 2: No Pain, No Gain
The assumption that soreness is the best indicator of a good workout is misleading. Muscle soreness, often attributed to micro-tears in muscle fibers, doesn’t necessarily correlate with muscle growth. Schoenfeld explains that soreness can result from novel exercises or changes in intensity, and it’s not an indicator of muscle damage. In fact, muscle damage is better assessed by a decrease in force output, not soreness. Over time, as your body adapts to a workout, you’ll experience less soreness—even as you continue to increase the intensity of your training.
Bottom Line: Soreness is not an essential marker of a successful workout. Focus on consistent progress rather than chasing the feeling of being sore.
Myth 3: Ice Baths Are Essential for Recovery
Cold water immersion, popularized by athletes and celebrities alike, is said to help reduce soreness and accelerate recovery. While ice baths can reduce short-term discomfort after intense workouts, they may hinder muscle growth. Research shows that immersing your body in cold water after strength training can impair the processes that promote muscle development. For instance, one study found that athletes who cycled after workouts experienced greater gains in muscle mass than those who took ice baths.
If you’re simply looking to ease soreness, an ice bath might be beneficial. But if you aim to build muscle, it’s best to skip the plunge after lifting weights.
Bottom Line: For muscle building, ice baths are counterproductive. If you’re seeking relief from soreness, moderate cold exposure may help, but avoid excessive cooling immediately post-workout.
Myth 4: Spot Reducing Fat Works
Many people are drawn to the idea that targeted exercises, such as crunches or arm curls, can specifically burn fat in those areas. Unfortunately, spot reduction is a myth. Strengthening a specific muscle does not directly lead to fat loss from that area. Fat loss is a whole-body process driven by a combination of genetics, diet, and overall exercise, not by isolated muscle work. Studies have shown that doing arm exercises on one side of the body does not lead to localized fat loss in that area.
Bottom Line: Fat loss is determined by genetics and overall calorie expenditure, not by focusing on specific muscle groups.
Myth 5: Women Will Bulk Up From Lifting Weights
The fear that weightlifting will make women “bulky” is widespread but unfounded. Due to hormonal differences, particularly lower levels of testosterone, women typically struggle to gain large amounts of muscle mass. Building substantial muscle requires a high level of consistency and a specific focus on strength training, which is not achieved by accident. Women who fear bulk from weightlifting should feel reassured that it takes significant effort and time to gain noticeable muscle mass. In fact, building muscle has numerous benefits, including improved metabolic function and bone health.
Bottom Line: Weightlifting won’t automatically make women bulky. Instead, it offers valuable health benefits, including stronger muscles and better overall fitness.
Myth 6: Running Will Damage Your Knees
A common belief is that running will wear out your knees over time. However, studies suggest the opposite may be true. Runners actually have a lower incidence of knee and hip osteoarthritis compared to non-runners. Jean-François Esculier, a researcher in physical therapy, notes that the act of running helps maintain cartilage health by stimulating nutrient flow, strengthening the joint tissue, and potentially reducing pain from arthritis. While elite runners may experience different outcomes, for the majority, running is beneficial for knee health.
Bottom Line: Running doesn’t harm the knees and may even protect against arthritis and other knee issues when done correctly. However, it’s crucial to listen to your body and gradually build up mileage to prevent injury.
Myth 7: Cardio Kills Your Muscle Gains
If you’re focused on building muscle, you might worry that cardio will hinder your progress. While it’s true that excessive aerobic exercise can interfere with strength training, moderate amounts of cardio do not negatively impact muscle growth. In fact, aerobic exercise can complement strength training by improving cardiovascular health and enhancing circulation, which aids recovery. The key is finding a balance—cardio in moderation won’t undo your hard work in the gym. Powerlifters or bodybuilders may need to adjust their cardio to avoid interfering with explosive strength gains, but for most people, cardio and strength training can coexist without issue.
Bottom Line: Cardio doesn’t undermine muscle development when done in moderation. Incorporating both aerobic and strength training into your routine can offer comprehensive health benefits.
Exercise myths are pervasive, but understanding the truth behind these misconceptions is key to optimizing your fitness routine. By dispelling these myths, you can approach your workouts with a clearer mindset, set realistic goals, and make informed decisions about your health.
Related Topics:
Do You Lose Weight with Strength Training
